|
The year was 1967; people across Canada celebrated
their country's 100th birthday. For Canadians from coast to coast it was
a time of optimism, a time when anything was possible.
For the people of Winnipeg, it was a double celebration.
Winnipeg was hosting a major international sporting event -- the Pan American
Games -- and, for the first time in history, people with disabilities
were part of the celebration. Immediately following the regular games,
Winnipeg would host the first Pan American Wheelchair Games. Athletes
with and without disabilities, from across North and South America, were
gathered in Winnipeg to compete for gold.
It is somehow fitting that 1967, the year that many
Canadians associate with our country's coming of age, was also the year
that Canadians with disabilities as a group began a journey of self-actualization
-- to take their place in society alongside able-bodied peers, family
and friends. The 1967 Pan Am Wheelchair Games was the first time in Canadian
history that so many people with disabilities came together to celebrate
abilities. These games helped set the tone for what was to become a full-blown
movement towards equality -- a movement that continues today, 34 years
later.
The Pan American Wheelchair Games was the first event
of its kind in the Americas, and it was the first time that people with
disabilities took direct responsibility for all aspects of planning and
organizing an event of this magnitude. While able-bodied volunteers were
involved in the games, key leadership positions were held by wheelchair
users. This was a bold step at a time when the majority of services for
people with disabilities were delivered by people without disabilities
-- able-bodied "professionals."
In retrospect, the Pan Am Wheelchair Games were as
much about self-determination as they were about sport.
The philosophy of self-determination was to become
a recurring theme in disability issues for the next four decades, as people
with various types of disabilities began to take responsibility for managing
their own lives.
It is fitting that the seeds of full participation
of people with disabilities were sown in the sporting arena. Through sport,
athletes develop valuable life skills: perseverance, commitment to excellence,
sportsmanship, confidence, self-esteem. It is in overcoming challenges,
in beating the odds, that we develop the confidence, the sense of self-worth,
that everyone needs to succeed. These attributes are critical to success
in our culture. And they are necessary if people with disabilities are
to overcome the additional obstacles related specifically to their disability.
Pan American athletes with disabilities came from
countries where they routinely confronted obstacles that their able-bodied
peers did not face -- physical and attitudinal barriers. But after the
Pan Am Games of '67, athletes returned home with a sense of accomplishment,
worthy of their country's praise! This was a new feeling, and a new beginning!
This story is about the man behind the 1967 Pan American
Wheelchair Games -- Allan Simpson. Allan was instrumental in the vision
of a first Pan Am Wheelchair Games. He travelled across North and South
America to drum up support, then returned to Winnipeg to direct the organization
of the games. The event was a springboard to greater heights as Allan
moved from being a leader in disability sports to being a leader in the
disability rights movement during the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, until his
death in 1998.
Allan Simpson is a man considered by many to be one
of the "Godfathers" of disability rights in Canada. A tireless worker,
Allan dedicated his life to helping others.
From the early 1960s, Allan Simpson was one of the
most influential persons advancing the interests of people with a disability
in Canada. In terms of sheer breadth of issues, Allan did much to improve
the quality of life of people with disabilities. He was a steadfast advocate,
working on issues at the local, provincial, national and international
levels -- wheelchair sports, housing, organizational development, social
policy, and promotion of individual responsibility and individual empowerment.
Allan's work was driven by a deeply held set of personal
beliefs. He felt that everyone, people with disabilities included, should
have the opportunity to direct their own lives, take responsibility for
themselves, make decisions and assume risks. Whether he was helping to
establish an organization, organizing a conference or assisting an individual,
Allan was focused in his efforts to help others help themselves. Allan's
vision was a society in which every person has an opportunity to make
a contribution.
Over the years, Allan was an inspiration and a mentor
to many people -- with and without disabilities. A forthright, caring,
generous individual, Allan's keen insight into human nature made him a
much sought-after counsel across Canada.
Having been accepted into the Order of the Buffalo
Hunt in 1995, one of Manitoba's highest honours, Allan was made a member
of the Order of Canada in 1998 in recognition of the value of his work
throughout this country. On October 22, together with former prime minister
Brian Mulroney and hockey legend Maurice "Rocket" Richard, Allan Simpson
was inducted into the Order of Canada at Rideau Hall in Ottawa.
Allan, while proud of this recognition, was also
humbled by it. At a Winnipeg ceremony celebrating his membership into
the Order of Canada, Allan publicly recognized the contributions of all
those with whom he had worked, saying that he had accepted the award on
behalf of many leaders in the disability movement. "This is a symbol of
all the tremendous work done by many people," Allan said.
On December 26, 1998, two months after accepting
the award, Allan died. He was 59. His death was unexpected, a shock to
many people across the country. There was a huge sense of loss in the
disability community.
People wondered openly whether anyone would ever
be able to fill the void in leadership that his death seemed to have created.
Fortunately for the disability movement, Allan's greatest legacy was the
strong collective voice of people with disabilities that he helped to
develop. The community of people with disabilities is filled with individuals
mentored by Allan. He had worked constantly to develop the leadership
skills and expand the knowledge base of people around him. At the time
of his death, Allan left behind scores of people who, over the years,
had become strong leaders in their own right.
George Dyck, a longtime friend and colleague, came
under Allan's influence in 1967 when Allan assigned him responsibility
for working out the logistics of the Pan Am Wheelchair Games. "I was thrown
into this pool -- it was sink or swim. My head was barely above the water
most of the time," says George, who was the director of facilities for
the games and was responsible for non-sport events such as the opening
ceremonies and transportation. "I learned so much that I gained confidence
in myself. After that, being on boards and committees just became a way
of life. I spend my days now going to board meetings."
On November 10, 1998, shortly before Allan's death,
Manitobans from all walks of life participated in an evening of celebration
to pay tribute to Allan. Allan only agreed to the event on the condition
that all Manitobans with disabilities who had previously received the
Order of Canada be recognized as well. It was clear from the beginning
of the evening, however, that this was Allan's night. Hundreds of people
paid respect to a truly great man, a man who used his gifts of wisdom,
wit and patience to serve others.
The progression of Allan's life parallels the evolution
of disability issues in Canada. Indeed, many would argue that the history
of disability in Canada and the history of Allan Simpson are synonymous.
Given his prominent role in so many of the events that make up the history
of disability in Canada, it is valid to ask whether Allan rode the wave
of history -- or generated it.
A politician at heart
As an organizer, Allan was a man not only with a
clear vision, but with the abilities to make that vision a reality. His
contributions remain unequaled. Will Rogers said, "The fellow that can
only see a week ahead is always the popular fellow, for he is looking
with the crowd. But the one that can see years ahead, he has a telescope,
but he can't make anybody believe that he has it." Allan had a telescope.
He approached disability issues like a game of chess, constantly thinking
four or five moves ahead. Before making his first move, he would anticipate
the response and develop a counter-response. On a variety of issues, Allan
was usually one step ahead of the others.
Allan genuinely enjoyed and understood politicals.
A believer in the democratic process, Allan knew that without active participation
in the political arena -- at all levels -- people's basic human rights
were not guaranteed. Disability was his political arena. In it, Allan
was effective at engaging politicians of all stripes. His political philosophy
was clearly inclusion, individual rights and responsibility.
A longtime friend, George Murphy, remembers a trip
to Ottawa with Allan in the early 1970s. On Parliament Hill, as the pair
sat waiting to enter the gallery for question period, then-Prime Minister
Pierre Trudeau himself came along, stopped and shook hands and spoke with
them. For question period, George and Allan were "hoisted up stairs,"
as the gallery was not wheelchair accessible. "Inaccessibility did not
daunt Allan," George says. "He was too busy watching what was going on
around him!"
George recalls how struck he was by Allan's reaction
to the House of Commons and question period. "Al was totally absorbed,"
he says. "It was then that I realized that this guy would make a great
federal or provincial representative, in terms of his abilities to communicate
and to move ahead with issues. This guy had the diplomacy of a Mike Pearson;
he had the tenacity of a Pierre Elliott Trudeau; he had the honesty and
integrity of a Stanley Knowles. For Allan, the process was often as important
as the outcome."
Even Allan's wife, Clare, acknowledged her husband's
political bent early in their marriage. To celebrate their wedding in
1973, Allan gave his new bride a beautiful engraved locket, which she
treasures to this day; Clare gave Allan a book on Lester B. Pearson! "A
strange gift, now that I think of it," she says, "but, at the time, I
guess I was acknowledging where his interests lay, and my hope that he
would continue his 'political' work with my support." Clare confesses
that "in private moments, Allan would talk about the possibility of entering
politics. I think he felt drawn to a political life."
Allan Simpson was a strategist. Whether in the boardroom,
socializing with friends, at home on the telephone with colleagues or
planning new initiatives at work, Allan was always thinking, planning
and networking.
According to Traci Walters, the national director
of the Canadian Association of Independent Living Centres (CAILC), "Allan's
real work began at the end of the day when the meeting was over." She
says that "he would get together with people on a one-to-one basis or
in small groups -- listen, share information, plot and plan. The next
day, he would make sure that outstanding issues would be put on the table
and addressed so that people always felt that their views were heard."
Allan had a 24-hour-a-day, seven-day-a-week commitment
to the work that he believed needed to be done. His energy and determination
seemed limitless.
Born in Ottawa on April 22, 1939, Allan was raised
in rural Manitoba (Moosehorn and Starbuck). When he was twelve his family
moved to Winnipeg where his father became the minister of Westworth United
Church. Allan was an active child who loved the outdoors and physical
sports such as football and baseball.
The polio epidemic was rampant in Winnipeg in the
late summer of 1953. His parents sent Allan to his grandparents in Moosehorn
to escape contact with the polio virus.
Allan was building a tree fort with several buddies
when he began to feel sick. That night, a Sunday in late August, Allan's
mother and father took him by car to the Winnipeg Municipal Hospital.
Allan's breathing became laboured on the way to the city. When the family
finally arrived at the hospital, they waited in line for an hour before
being admitted.
It was a devastating time for the family. For four
weeks Allan, who had indeed contracted polio, lived in an iron lung. His
mother was unable to visit the hospital, as she was pregnant with a third
son. Allan's father gained admittance only because he wore a clerical
collar. After a lengthy ten-month hospital stay, Allan returned home.
He was no longer able to walk and had limited upper-body mobility.
Allan received wonderful support from his family
(his mother, father and two brothers, David and Donald) and his "church
family." He did, however, face many challenges. At the top of the list
were the barriers to going back to school -- there were no accessible
schools within a reasonable distance of his home. He had to resort to
learning by correspondence.
It was because of his own correspondence schooling
in 1953 that George Murphy first came to know Allan. Both boys shared
the same Grade 10 tutor, Mrs. McLean. "She would come to visit me and
say that Allan was doing great, motivating me to go beyond where I was.
I was left with the thought, 'Who is this Simpson character?'" says George.
"Later on, when we finally met face to face, Allan had the same story
-- Mrs. McLean was challenging him by telling him how well Murphy
was doing!"
By the time he had completed Grades 9 and 10 at home,
Allan was well enough to get on with his life. He announced to his parents
that he wanted to return to school for Grade 11. Although Allan was now
limited in his mobility, he was a healthy teenager with a strong desire
to spend time with people his own age.
After contacting several schools, only to be turned
down, Allan's parents approached Gordon Bell High School. The principal
agreed to let Allan attend in the fall of 1955. Allan graduated with his
class in 1958. He went on to attend the University of Manitoba, where
he graduated in 1962 with a Bachelor of Commerce (Honours), specializing
in actuarial mathematics. Because his disability was physical, it had
no bearing on his academic pursuits, other than affecting how he got to
classes -- which, for the most part, were not wheelchair accessible --
and how he took notes.
In fact, Allan was exposed to transportation and
architectural barriers throughout high school and university. Undaunted,
he organized groups of friends to carpool him to school, and to lift him
up and down flights of stairs for classes. It was during this period that
Allan honed his organizational skills.
Determined to be as independent as possible, Allan
arranged to have a car equipped with hand controls suited to his level
of strength (a very uncommon adaptation in the early '60s), and taught
his family and friends how to get him in and out of the car. When he began
his first job with Monarch Life Assurance Co. in 1962 as an actuarial
student, he used his own car to get to and from work.
Allan never hesitated to ask people for assistance,
and this enabled him to accomplish many things. Art Bilodeau, his co-worker
at Monarch Life, witnessed the way Allan was able to mobilize teams of
people to help him manage at the office. Allan lined up five fellows,
one for each day of the week, who would meet him in the morning, get him
out of the car and into the office, and then back again at the end of
the day. It was a system that worked for eleven years. In 1975 Allan advanced
to a power wheelchair and an accessible van to enhance his mobility.
Two individuals had a great influence on Allan's
attitudes, pursuits and ideals during the 1960s and 1970s. Tony Mann,
executive director of the Canadian Paraplegic Association (CPA) (Manitoba),
and himself paraplegic, assisted Allan and his family with contacts for
academic tutoring and access to university. As Allan was graduating from
U of M, Tony recognized in him a determination and a strength of spirit.
He challenged him to become involved with the CPA, and particularly the
development of wheelchair sports in Manitoba. (This was what ultimately
led to Allan's position as managing director of the first Pan American
Wheelchair Games in 1967.) Tony Mann was an inspiration to Allan -- Tony's
passion for challenging inaccessible systems, his drive, his long hours
of work and dedication, all had a profound effect on Allan's life.
Leon Mitchell, a prominent lawyer in Winnipeg and
also a polio survivor, worked for years with CPA and the Manitoba Wheelchair
Sports and Recreation Association, lending them his brilliant mind, his
commitment to disability issues and his determination to effect change.
Leon Mitchell and Tony Mann were important mentors to Allan, and the death
of these two men several years ago represented a big loss.
Leadership for Allan was about taking action. When
the Organizing Committee of the Pan American Games refused to meet about
the possibility of holding demonstration wheelchair basketball games during
the regular Pan Am Games, George Dyck recalls that Allan threatened the
committee with a public rally. "He was going to parade downtown if they
did not talk to him," George says. "They finally gave in. That to me symbolizes
the kind of pit-bull type of attitude that Allan had. When he believed
in something, there was nothing going to get in his way."
Allan counselled George, "If you can't go straight
ahead, go around. There is always a way. If you meet a brick wall, don't
bang your head against it -- back up, and find another way."
Let the games begin
For twenty-one years (1962-1983), Allan was a man
with two careers. He was an actuary and computer systems analyst with
Monarch Life Assurance Co., and he was a dedicated volunteer and advocate
on disability issues. He was equally committed to both; he could often
be found at disability-related meetings during regular business hours,
and working at Monarch Life late into the night.
April D'Aubin was a policy analyst with the Council
of Canadians with Disabilities (CCD) during Allan's term as chairman of
the disability rights organization. She remembers their early-morning
meetings: "We would meet in Allan's office at Monarch Life, where he would
give us our marching orders for the day."
During the early 1960s Allan was an active member
of the Monday-Night Club, a social group for people with disabilities.
Through this club, Allan had come to realize that there was a vacuum in
the lives of wheelchair users in Winnipeg. Although many of them lived
in the community and were employed, most continued to live socially isolated
lives. Whether due to limited physical access or lack of willingness to
accommodate, there simply weren't many social outlets for people with
disabilities. Wheelchair sport was a rare exception. So, although he didn't
play, Allan strongly supported it.
In 1965, when Allan learned that Winnipeg would play
host to the 1967 Pan American Games, he saw an opportunity to profile
the abilities of wheelchair athletes by including wheelchair basketball
as a demonstration sport in the mainstream games. It was a radical idea
at the time (the first international sporting event to integrate wheelchair
sports was the 1994 Pan Am Games in Victoria), and although Allan finally
convinced the Organizing Committee to meet about it, they rejected the
idea.
Undaunted by the refusal, Allan conceived the idea
of an independent event following the games, and formed a committee to
prepare a proposal. Thanks largely to Allan's persuasive nature and a
few key political contacts, his group was able to secure a grant of $17,000.
They proceeded to implement Canada's first international wheelchair games
-- the Pan American Wheelchair Games.
With the exception of table tennis, Allan was no
athlete. But what he did like was to strategize, to plan and to make things
happen. His involvement with the Pan Am Games had less to do with love
of sports and more to do with taking advantage of an opportunity, one
that challenged his skills and, at the same time, provided a venue for
furthering the issues of disability.
"He had a very active brain. He played chess with
champions -- actual Grand Masters. He was good at strategy," says George
Dyck. "I think that there was an itch in his brain, and he had to scratch
that part of his brain where he could organize things and make them happen."
The games were two years in the planning. Allan,
at 26, was appointed the managing director. He created an executive committee
of people with and without disabilities -- anyone with the time and willingness
to help. George Dyck, George Murphy, Joe Smithson and Merv Thomson, all
wheelchair users and all members of the Monday-Night Club, were key committee
chairmen.
The obstacles appeared endless. First, while fledgling,
local wheelchair sport groups existed across Canada, there was no local,
national or international infrastructure. Allan had to find people to
participate. In 1965 he travelled on his own to Mexico, visited rehab
centres and sold the idea of sending a Mexican team to the games. The
message gradually caught on in other South American countries which, up
until then, knew little about wheelchair sports.
Second, the logistics of hosting more than a hundred
wheelchair users at a time when accessible accommodations were almost
non-existent, there was no accessible public transportation and accessible
sporting venues were hard to find would be a nightmare.
Third, there was the question of how to ensure the
participation of athletes from across the Americas when many people with
disabilities didn't even have wheelchairs, let alone the funds to come
to Canada for a sporting event.
These challenges, rather than thwarting the committee
members, spurred them on. Through mail, ham radios and physical travel
across North and South America, they spread the word. They even provided
equipment and funding to some countries to ensure their athletes could
participate. They were able to secure accommodation and transportation
in Winnipeg through personal contacts. And since many of the Pan Am Games
venues -- some only recently built -- were inaccessible, alternate venues
were found.
Notwithstanding the numerous obstacles, the Pan American
Wheelchair Games were held in Winnipeg from August 8 to August 13, 1967.
The five-day event was a resounding success.
One hundred and thirty-five athletes from eight countries
-- Argentina, Canada, Columbia, Jamaica, Mexico, Peru, Trinidad and Tobago
and the United States -- competed in twelve events, including track and
field, archery, rifle and pistol, volleyball, swimming and the pentathlon.
In addition to the sporting events, an array of extracurricular activities
-- barbecues, dances and parties -- had been organized to occupy non-sport
hours.
While only some of the athletes would leave the games
with medals, all of them would leave with fond memories of Winnipeg and
Canada.
Two significant organizations were established as
a result of these games. First, a Pan American Wheelchair Games Council
was formed to arrange wheelchair games and higher standards of competition
for the Pan American countries. During the initial council meetings it
was agreed that Buenos Aires, Argentina, would host the next Pan Am Wheelchair
Games in 1969, and it was expected that Cali, Columbia, would host the
1971 games.
Second, on November 24, 1967, only three months after
the games, the Canadian Wheelchair Sports Association was created. Now
there was a national and international infrastructure to promote wheelchair
sports.
Allan was the first executive director of the Canadian
Wheelchair Sports Association.
The media coverage of the first Pan American Wheelchair
Games allowed all Manitobans -- indeed, all Canadians -- to witness firsthand
the abilities of people with disabilities. Certainly Allan had been committed
to the games for the sake of the athletes (they demonstrated to other
wheelchair users that they, too, could achieve in a competitive environment);
but, forever the strategist, Allan had also known that the games would
be a catalyst for change -- change from which all Canadians with disabilities
would benefit.
Allan was able to use the games to demonstrate to
local businesses the benefits of access. He was able to convince the city
of the need for accessible local transportation. Finally, he knew that
the attitudes of the general public would be forever changed.
"We are no longer stared at or seen as an oddity,"
Allan said in a 1995 interview. "That's progress."
Another legacy of the games was that Allan himself
had become known in Winnipeg and around the world as a man who could make
things happen. While many people talk about change, Allan had put his
money where his mouth was and proven to the world that he could succeed.
His reputation as someone who could get the job done was secured.
Leveraging opportunities became a hallmark for Allan,
one he would use over and over again throughout his lifetime. For Allan,
every activity served multiple purposes. Whether it was a conference,
sporting event or kite-flying festival, Allan used the occasion to encourage
people with disabilities and to engage the community in general.
Giving a voice to the disability rights movement
By the 1970s, Allan began looking beyond the needs
of people with physical disabilities, and began examining strategies to
address the needs of people with different types of disabilities. In 1971,
in addition to being the executive director of both the Canadian and Manitoba
Wheelchair Sports Associations, Allan was a board member of the Canadian
Paraplegic Association. The CPA dealt with a broader range of issues than
wheelchair sports, and as Allan began to recognize the need for more accessible
housing, schools and transportation, he also recognized that people with
other types of disabilities -- blindness, deafness and others -- were
facing similar issues.
There was a growing trend across North America toward
social activism for civil rights. Allan, along with a few others, decided
that a provincial organization was needed to lobby for the rights of all
Manitobans with disabilities. They created the Manitoba League of People
with Disabilities (MLPD).
Allan's wife, Clare, points out that one of the frustrations
among people with disabilities in Winnipeg had been in dealing with service
agencies staffed by non-disabled social workers and psychologists. "Allan
came to a realization that there was little voice for people with disabilities.
People were directed where to go, whether they had the potential for university
[for example], or not."
The Manitoba League of People with Disabilities was
unique in two ways. While existing organizations for people with disabilities
were either service oriented (e.g. recreational services) or disability
specific, the MLPD would lobby on behalf of all people with disabilities.
Second, its bylaws required a majority of board members to be people with
disabilities, thus ensuring that consumers would maintain control of their
issues.
Leaving the sporting movement in capable hands, Allan
immersed himself in disability rights. He invited disability representatives
from other provinces to the inaugural meeting of the MLPD, leading to
the formation of other provincial bodies and, two years later in 1974,
of Canada's national cross-disability rights organization -- the Council
of Canadians with Disabilities (originally called the Coalition of Provincial
Organizations of the Handicapped, or COPOH). Allan sat on the boards of
both the MLPD and COPOH, chairing COPOH from 1979 to 1982.
Allan shepherded COPOH through an extremely tumultuous
period of Canadian history. The rights of people with disabilities competed
for public and media attention with issues such as Quebec sovereignty,
minority rights, Aboriginal rights, the National Energy Program, high
inflation and, most importantly, the patriation of the constitution.
It was his work with this last issue and a supporting
charter of rights that was perhaps Allan's most significant contribution
to equality rights of people with disabilities in Canada.
Citizens and their representative organizations from
across Canada were consulted. Disability organizations, particularly COPOH,
were involved throughout the process. Allan, working closely with COPOH's
executive director, Jim Derksen, and a small group of people across the
country, lobbied heavily for the protection of the rights of people with
disabilities within the charter.
Prime Minister Jean Chrétien was at that time
the Minister of Justice, the department responsible for the charter. "We
put a process in place to consult with Canadians. Disability groups were
part of that process," says Mr. Chrétien. "Their presentations
to the committee were the reason why disabled persons were included in
the charter."
He confirms that then-Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau
also gave full support to including the rights of people with disabilities
in Section 15 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms: "If Mr. Trudeau
had not supported it," Mr. Chrétien acknowledges, "it would not
have happened."
Today, Section 15 of the charter stands as one of
the most significant milestones in the history of disability in Canada.
It contends that Canadians with disabilities cannot be legally or systemically
excluded from active participation in their community. Individuals and
groups of people with disabilities have used the charter in several precedent-setting
Supreme Court cases, including the Latimer case.
With COPOH, as with wheelchair sports, Allan saw
his role as twofold: to work with his colleagues to address issues, and
to encourage the development of healthy leadership in the disability community.
He ensured the latter by constantly providing opportunities for new people
with disabilities to participate in his organizations' activities. Whenever
he attended a public meeting or a national board meeting Allan made sure
that new recruits were constantly brought into the decision-making circles.
"He helped individuals identify their gifts, and
helped them overcome their fears by focusing on the task at hand," says
April D'Aubin.
Indeed, Laurie Beachell, on his first day of work
as the national director of the CCD, was invited by Allan to a meeting
with politicians to discuss disability issues. "Allan had given me a briefing
the night before," he says. The next day at the meeting, Allan introduced
Laurie to the politicians and then, turning to him, asked him to explain
the issues at hand. "It wasn't that he was trying to set me up or make
me look foolish; he simply wanted to give me an opportunity to take charge.
Fortunately, he was there to help me out when it came to questions I couldn't
answer!"
"Housing defines us"
During the 1970s, Allan studied other issues that
affected the participation of people with disabilities in their communities
-- particularly housing and transportation. Allan believed that if more
people with disabilities lived alongside able-bodied neighbours, they
would be less socially isolated and would develop networks and friendships,
which would lead to a higher degree of integration.
While many people with disabilities could and did
live independently, those with disabilities significant enough to require
assistance with routine activities of daily living -- getting up in the
morning, or going to bed at night -- had only two options. They could
live with family members who provided support, or they could live in long-term
care institutions. Both options were often less than ideal. Allan worked
with a group of people with significant disabilities in Winnipeg to come
up with a solution.
That solution was Ten Ten Sinclair. Built in 1975,
Ten Ten Sinclair was to be a transitional living environment in which
adults with disabilities would develop the skills necessary to live independently
in the community. It was an integrated housing complex for tenants with
and without disabilities. Of its 75 units, almost two-thirds were wheelchair
accessible. People in the accessible units would have access to personal
attendants to help them with routine tasks.
Ten Ten Sinclair proved a success on many levels.
It reintroduced people with disabilities to the community. Among the able-bodied
tenants of the complex, awareness was raised of the abilities of the tenants
with disabilities. In addition, the cost of supporting people with disabilities
in the community was less than half the cost of keeping them in institutions.
As Ten Ten Sinclair was a transitional living model,
people were expected to move in, develop their skills and move out. While
this worked in some cases, it didn't in others, as people were faced with
nowhere to go. Under Allan's direction, Ten Ten Sinclair expanded its
mandate to look at a variety of housing options, including permanent units
where people requiring high levels of support could still live in their
community. Ten Ten Sinclair began to develop "clusters," where small numbers
of people with disabilities lived in an integrated environment and were
still able to receive the supports they required to live independently.
Today, Ten Ten Sinclair operates with a budget in
excess of $4-million and offers support to hundreds of people with disabilities
-- at a cost well below that of institutions.
Shortly after Allan would become executive director
of Winnipeg's Independent Living Resource Centre (ILRC), he would begin
to develop another community living model to complement the options available
through Ten Ten Sinclair. Allan and other ILRC members would develop a
self-directed attendant service option whereby people with disabilities
would be given the responsibility to manage their service needs. Within
this model, the government would provide each individual with funding
and it would be up to them to manage their own attendants. People with
disabilities would recruit, hire and train staff, pay wages and appropriate
Canada Pension Plan contributions, even fire staff if necessary. As an
empowerment tool, it would be without precedent! People in Winnipeg would
have a range of options from which to choose.
"Allan certainly talked about the role of housing,
and that housing was fundamental," says Milton Sussman, former director
of Ten Ten Sinclair. "His view was that housing wasn't just the physical
building, it was clearly all the supports you needed to be able to live
independently. I think he saw it as the core of what makes people able
to function independently." Milton adds that this philosophy reflects
"a high degree of wisdom. Housing really does, in many ways, define us.
It does give us that functional ability, and you see it in the choices
that people make."
Whenever Allan moved from one organization to another,
he left behind a legacy of work and a group of people with the skills
to carry on. However, Allan never completely left the issues that he felt
strongly about. He made himself available whenever solicited, and often
when not.
The telephone was Allan's tool to keep things moving.
He used it well. His wife Clare recalls many evenings when Allan was on
the phone with a host of different groups. Both Laurie Beachell and Traci
Walters refer to Allan's Sunday-night telephone calls, both of which occurred
like clockwork -- at 9:00 p.m. for Traci and 10:00 p.m. for Laurie --
to discuss the upcoming week.
"When Allan passed away," says Laurie, "an important
communication link between organizations was lost. Although no one really
recognized it at the time, Allan's constant link with each of the groups
had the effect of keeping them all moving in the same direction."
Allan had enough energy for two, and a passion for
work. But he wasn't all seriousness. Milton Sussman says, "One of the
things that struck me about Allan is that he was a very hearty guy and
he enjoyed having a good time." He became familiar with Allan's sense
of humour and points out that even in the midst of "dealing with all of
these pretty heavy kinds of issues, he was enthusiastic and you got the
sense that he had a good time."
Overcoming obstacles to be a family
Allan was a pioneer in many areas, his personal life
included.
With Allan's full schedule -- all his advocacy work
added to his already busy schedule with Monarch Life -- one would think
that there wasn't much time left for a social life. But one day, while
Allan was visiting the offices of the Canadian Paraplegic Association,
an employee from an office down the hall caught Allan's attention. Her
name was Clare McMorran. Clare also used a wheelchair as a result of polio.
She had been raised in a small town outside of Winnipeg and had never
really had anything to do with disability organizations or wheelchair
sports.
This spunky young woman who didn't seem interested
in disability issues intrigued Allan. He invited her out to a disability
event he was organizing. Before long, they were dating.
"He was interesting, outgoing and very involved in
many things," says Clare. "We struggled with the image of both being wheelchair
users, but eventually our feelings and love for each other went beyond
the concern for image." Clare and Allan married in 1973.
They broke ground together in 1979 when they adopted
a child -- two wheelchair users adopting a child without a disability.
The experience would be memorable for any couple, but it was especially
monumental for the Simpsons.
The process began in 1976. Shortly after Allan and
Clare attended a Children's Aid Society (CAS) group orientation meeting
to meet staff and to pick up an adoption application package, the CAS
called to schedule a meeting at their home. Clare remembers the day vividly.
"We both came home from work early and we were excited to meet these two
people from Children's Aid," she says. But, to her surprise, "they came
that day asking us to withdraw our application... Those were pretty well
the first words that they said when they came in and sat down."
Clare was shocked by the overt discrimination. Allan
was a professional with sixteen years of work experience. Clare was working
but wanted to be a stay-at-home mother. They were ideal candidates for
adoptive parents. The only difference between them and other couples were
their disabilities.
The CAS agents claimed to be concerned about the
best interests of the child. "The hair just rose on the back of our necks,"
says Clare. "Maybe Allan had more perception that this might happen. We
had never, to my knowledge, talked about this as a possibility." She had
felt confident in their ability to be parents, and had not considered
that there might be such a major problem. Many of their friends with disabilities
had successfully adopted children, but in those families, only the men
used a wheelchair. "Their main concern was that I was in a chair --
the mother."
Clare and Allan began to talk about how they would
deal with various issues such as safety. After a couple of hours, Clare
says, "We finally got to the point. We wanted the same home study as other
prospective parents."
The CAS representatives finally agreed to the home
study, but told them not to get their hopes up. The possibility of adoption
now appeared remote.
"We had many, many, many interviews," says Clare.
A social worker, "who turned out to be a wonderful, supportive person,"
was assigned to assess them. "It was a little scary. But she looked into
our lifestyles very closely -- each of us individually, and together as
a couple. It sure helped us really dig deep in terms of what we thought
we could provide to a child."
The three-year adoption process took an emotional
toll on Allan and Clare. Although Allan had worked for more than a decade
on disability issues, this had been his first personal experience with
flagrant discrimination. It was a wake-up call of sorts, emphasizing for
him the need for constant vigilance -- to be prepared to continually fight
for the rights of all people with disabilities. CAS had assumed, without
talking to Allan and Clare first, that these two people with disabilities
could not care for a child. Had they not been able to convince the agency
otherwise, Allan and Clare would never have had the opportunity to adopt
children, and their girls would not have had the chance to experience
their love.
They adopted Julie in 1979, and Katherine (Katie)
in 1984 (they did not encounter additional barriers for the second adoption).
Both girls have grown into attractive, articulate young women.
"Dad was busy but he always made time to spend with
us," says Julie "He would take me to soccer and other things. He made
a point of spending alone time with each of us."
Katherine remembers that her father was always trying
to teach her something. They played chess together. "He really liked chess.
He would use it to teach me how to think strategically."
To Katherine and Julie, their parents were the same
as the able-bodied parents of their friends. They just used wheelchairs
to get around. But in other ways, their father was indeed special. Julie
says that "after he died, we read all the articles that were published
and heard stories about what an amazing man our father was. As kids we
generally knew what he did, but not really. We now have a lot of memories."
Clare concedes that Allan gave his life to the community
of people with disabilities. He did it because of his passion for individual
rights and his love for engaging in organizational politics. "As a household,
we remember the phone always ringing, the interesting personalities who
stayed at our home from Sweden, Africa and Trinidad, Dad in the media
again." But it is very important to know that Allan always had time for
his family -- for Clare, Julie and Katherine -- and for his extended family.
Clare says, "We designed and built our accessible home together, shared
time cheering on our girls on the baseball and soccer fields, were proud
parents at school Christmas concerts and graduations." Clare says that
she and Allan shared a deep faith and were active in their church.
She also says that her husband loved to travel "and
instilled in the rest of us the challenge of taking to the open road to
find adventure and meet new people." They took family trips to Germany,
France, Austria, Mexico and across Canada. "He climbed a mountain with
the girls in Banff, and explored new trails."
Their last journey as a family was to Ottawa to watch
Allan be inducted into the Order of Canada. The morning of the ceremony,
Allan set about to take his daughters on a tour of the Parliament Buildings.
"We travelled the halls, went to the door of the prime minister's office,
sat and listened to proceedings from the gallery," says Clare. "In reflecting
on this trip now, Julie, Katie and I know so well the energy and devotion
Allan had towards his work and his country and his family."
Pioneering the Independent Living movement in
Canada
By the early 1980s, the wheelchair sports and disability
rights movements were going strong, and more people were living outside
of institutions. However, Allan recognized that the vast majority of people
with disabilities still were not able to participate fully in their community.
What does an individual with a disability need in
order to be a full, functioning member of society? By this time, Allan
had acknowledged that sports were not an option for all people with disabilities,
and that elite sport was accessible to even fewer. Thus the personal benefits
of empowerment and self-esteem associated with athletics weren't available
to the majority of people with disabilities in Canada. The issue of personal
development had not been adequately addressed for most Canadians with
disabilities.
There remained other barriers as well. One of the
most significant was lack of control of one's own destiny. The services
and supports on which Canadians with disabilities relied in order to function
in their community were still being developed and delivered primarily
by non-disabled people and did not always meet their needs or expectations.
Without adequate community-based supports, many people with disabilities
were limited in their level of independence, access to education and opportunity
to develop employment and related skills. The issue of who set the priorities
still needed to be addressed.
A new social movement was emerging south of the border
-- the Independent Living (IL) movement. Conceived in Berkeley, California,
the IL movement was founded on the principle of consumer direction. Fundamentally,
the movement is about people taking control of their own lives. Priorities
were set by those most affected by an issue. Programs based on the philosophy
of self-direction were developed. Independent Living Resource Centres
(ILRCs) arose in the United States that provided a combination of empowerment,
information-sharing and personal advocacy services to help equip people
with disabilities with the tools necessary to take their rightful place
in their community.
In the early '80s Allan's own environment was changing.
While he contemplated a career move, the new owners of Monarch Life contemplated
a move of their own -- relocating the headquarters to Ontario. It seemed
as if fate had intervened. Allan was offered a job with the new head office
but didn't want to leave his home city. After years of having a foot in
two camps, he felt he was ready to step the rest of the way into one camp
where he could do the things he enjoyed most -- strategizing, lobbying,
playing politics and, most importantly, serving clients with disabilities.
This was the first time Allan had ever considered
leaving his job with Monarch Life and taking a paid position in an area
where he'd been a volunteer for so long. Was it a wise career move? Would
he be as effective a lobbyist if decision-makers believed his motivation
was self-interest rather than helping others? After much thought and discussion
with friends and family, Allan decided to take the step. Allan had worked
hard at Monarch Life, but his heart had long been in disability issues.
Allan Simpson became the executive director of Canada's
first Independent Living Resource Centre -- established in 1983 in Winnipeg,
Manitoba.
For Allan, the Independent Living Resource Centre
was an opportunity to put into practice some of his long-held beliefs
-- that people with even significant disabilities could manage their own
lives, using professionals as resources, not being directed by them. And
he knew that in order for people to manage their own affairs, they had
to be empowered.
In his new position, Allan worked with others across
the country to stimulate ILRCs in other provinces. In 1985 he helped to
establish the national ILRC umbrella organization, the Canadian Association
of Independent Living Centres. By the end of the decade, there were 18
Canadian ILRCs in communities from coast to coast.
By the end of the '80s, after having spent three
decades developing and implementing strategies for personal empowerment
and collective advocacy, Allan continued to witness the marginalization
of people with disabilities. While unemployment among people with disabilities
was lower, it was still more than twice the national average of that of
non-disabled Canadians.
In 1990, people with disabilities represented 15.2
per cent of the Canadian population. Under-represented in the work force,
people with disabilities were over-represented in the ranks of the poor,
marginalized and socially isolated. They lacked reasonable access to community
housing and public transportation in most cities, and were generally limited
in their ability to participate in their communities. The playing field
was still not level for people with disabilities. Although statistics
showed that quality of life had improved, it remained well below that
of other Canadians.
Allan was by now recognized in Canada and around
the world as one of the country's senior statesmen on disability issues.
He was a resource to decision makers everywhere. Although many did not
always agree with Allan, they respected his commitment and his ability
to understand issues from all sides. Among politicians and bureaucrats,
Allan was valued for his intelligence and his insight, and among family
and friends for his dedication, compassion and selflessness. He was recognized
by everyone as a man who had the ability to get things done.
By 1990, Allan had turned his attention to the broader
issue of social reform. He was particularly concerned about the devolution
of social programs from the federal government to the provinces brought
about by the recession and huge federal deficits of the mid-1990s. Allan
interpreted the transfer of powers as a loss of national standards and
consistency. In particular, he believed that the Canada Health and
Social Transfer (CHST) Act represented the first step toward the potential
destruction of the values and institutions that had been established to
ensure that Canadians with disabilities would have the supports they needed
to participate in all aspects of society. In fact, Allan believed the
CHST to be detrimental to all citizens, not just those with disabilities,
and remained vehemently opposed to the act and its underlying philosophy
the rest of his life.
Throughout his lifetime, Allan remained an ardent
federalist. He believed in Canada and what it stood for. Canada truly
was the best place in the world to live -- Allan knew this long before
the United Nations recognized it. However, he also recognized that individual
and human rights are fragile and that, if we want to maintain these rights,
we citizens have to be willing to fight for them.
In 1997, the Prime Minister held a First Ministers'
meeting to discuss social issues at the Foreign Affairs Building on Sussex
Drive in Ottawa. The CCD held a demonstration on the front lawn outside
the meeting to protest the devolution of social programs without strong
national standards from the federal government to the provinces. Usually
a behind-the-scenes networker, Allan could and did take to the public
stage when he believed it would serve his purpose. He was front-and-centre
during the 1997 protest, carrying a placard that read, "STOP Ignoring
Disabled People!"
The 1990s saw the emergence of another issue that
concerned Allan greatly -- assisted suicide. Allan was a staunch opponent
of assisted suicide and worked closely with the CCD to develop an organizational
position. Assisted suicide has major implications for the disability community,
as many people with disabilities over the years have been "helped" by
others to end their lives. Personal experience had taught Allan that the
perceptions of the average person working in the health care system regarding
the quality of life experienced by people with disabilities was low. As
such, these personnel tended to encourage people with disabilities to
accept an easy and comfortable death rather than pursue aggressive measures
to continue life. Allan fought this attitude. When his grandmother experienced
an illness that required her to be hospitalized, Allan became her advocate,
working to ensure that her options were not limited by negative perceptions
of her quality of life.
Holding him in our hearts
Allan initiated a fanciful gift to his community
in the early 1990s. The annual Winnipeg Kite Flying Festival was, on one
level, a fundraiser for the not-for-profit Independent Living Resource
Centre. But it was also much more. The event was to be organized and run
by people with disabilities. Allan explained it as an opportunity for
people with disabilities to do something for their community -- to give
something back to the city of Winnipeg. The festival was also a forum
to show the public that people with disabilities were capable, contributing
citizens of Winnipeg. And it was an opportunity to become more comfortable
in interactions with people with disabilities.
Allan's mind never stopped. He was constantly thinking
up innovative ways to push his message of inclusion. With humour, compassion
and insight, Allan epitomized what it is to be Canadian.
Throughout his life, Allan remained committed to
his values -- that everyone was equal and therefore deserving of an opportunity
to participate equally in society -- and to his vision -- that, by working
together, we can make Canada the best place in the world for people with
disabilities to live.
A natural leader, Allan used his skills to change
the way Canada relates to its citizens with disabilities. As a mentor
and role model, he used his skills to change the way citizens with disabilities
viewed themselves -- and, in so doing, helped them develop their own skills
and abilities.
Allan was a remarkable individual. His friends and
family are still paying tribute to his life and his legacy.
"Al gave us a heck of a good run," says George Murphy,
"and we have enjoyed every moment."
Adds George Dyck: "We went to a place we would have
never gone."
And Allan's wife, Clare, has her own lasting words
from her husband. "In the last couple of years before his death, Allan
knew his energy levels were decreasing." Yet, "day after day, night after
night, Allan advocated on behalf of countless individuals and organizations
with such determination." One evening after Allan got home from intervening
on behalf of a person who did not have the strength to lobby for his needs,
Clare said to her husband: "How will we ever remember all the contributions
that you make?
"He answered, 'Clare, when I am gone, just carry
on the work...'
"I hold this conversation in my heart," says Clare.
"It speaks to all of us in the disability movement."
|